The Baker Mayfield MVP train is officially rolling, and everyone\’s jumping on board like it\’s the last ride out of Cleveland. But before you start printing those \”MVP Baker\” t-shirts, we need to have a serious conversation about what\’s really happening here and why it reveals the most uncomfortable truth in all of football.
The Perfect Storm Pattern
Let\’s talk about a pattern that keeps repeating itself in the NFL, and somehow nobody wants to acknowledge it exists. Remember when Brock Purdy was the \”next big thing\” a few years ago? Everyone was ready to crown him the future of the position. Then there was Jared Goff putting together what looked like MVP-caliber seasons. And who could forget Sam Darnold last year before he completely fell off a cliff?
What did all these guys have in common? They weren\’t just playing good football – they were playing in perfect situations. Clean pockets, receivers running wide open routes, offensive lines giving them all day to throw, and systems so well-designed they could practically run themselves.
But here\’s the thing about perfect storms – they don\’t last forever. Eventually the weather changes, the pressure comes, and you find out who can actually swim when the tide goes out.
When Reality Hits Different
The moment these \”system quarterbacks\” faced real adversity, everything fell apart. Pressure up the middle? Suddenly those perfectly placed passes started sailing high. Primary receiver covered? Panic mode activated. The offensive line having an off day? Welcome to turnover city.
Meanwhile, guys like Patrick Mahomes are out here turning broken plays into SportsCenter highlights. Josh Allen is making throws that shouldn\’t be physically possible. Joe Burrow is threading needles with defenders draped all over him. These guys don\’t just survive when the system breaks down – they thrive.
The Tale of Two Quarterback Types
This is where we get to the uncomfortable truth that nobody in the NFL media wants to admit. There are basically two types of quarterbacks in this league, and the difference between them is massive.
You\’ve got your system quarterbacks who need everything to be perfect. The right play call, the right protection, the right route combinations, the receivers in the right spots at the right time. When all those pieces align, they look like world-beaters. But take away even one or two of those elements, and they start looking very ordinary, very quickly.
Then you have the transcendent quarterbacks who don\’t just work within their system – they make their system work. These are the guys who turn third-and-long into magic. They make their receivers look better than they actually are. They find ways to succeed even when everything around them is falling apart.
The Baker Mayfield Question
Which brings us back to Baker Mayfield and this MVP hype. Look, the guy is having a hell of a season, and he deserves credit for that. But let\’s be honest about what we\’re really looking at here.
Baker is surrounded by Mike Evans and Chris Godwin, two receivers who could make a lot of quarterbacks look good. He\’s got Emeka Egbuka adding another weapon to the mix. That Tampa Bay offensive line is giving him time to operate. The system is humming along perfectly.
So the real question isn\’t whether Baker is playing well – he obviously is. The question is what happens when that perfect storm inevitably ends. What happens when Evans gets hurt? What happens when that offensive line starts breaking down? What happens when opposing defenses figure out how to disrupt Tampa Bay\’s rhythm?
The Data Doesn\’t Lie
Here\’s what the numbers tell us about quarterbacks when everything goes to hell. When the pocket collapses and the scripted plays stop working, there\’s a massive separation between the pretenders and the contenders. The system guys start throwing picks and taking sacks. The transcendent guys start making magic happen.
It\’s not even close when you look at the stats. Completion percentage under pressure, touchdown-to-interception ratio on broken plays, ability to extend drives when the initial read isn\’t there – the elite guys dominate these categories while the system quarterbacks struggle.
The MVP Mirage
This MVP conversation around Baker Mayfield isn\’t really about Baker Mayfield at all. It\’s about recognizing the difference between individual excellence and situational success. It\’s about understanding that sometimes what looks like MVP-caliber play is actually just really good system execution.
That doesn\’t take anything away from Baker\’s performance this season. Playing quarterback in the NFL is hard as hell, even with perfect conditions. But there\’s a difference between being really good in a great situation and being truly elite regardless of the circumstances.
The Inevitable Reality Check
Every season, we see this same story play out. Some quarterback starts hot in a perfect system, the MVP talk begins, and everyone acts like this time is different. Then the schedule gets harder, injuries pile up, defenses adjust, and suddenly that MVP candidate looks a lot more mortal.
The truly great quarterbacks weather those storms and keep producing. The system guys? They remind us why context matters more than we want to admit.
The Bigger Picture
This isn\’t just about Baker Mayfield or even this year\’s MVP race. This is about how we evaluate quarterback play in general and whether we\’re honest about what we\’re actually seeing. Are we watching individual brilliance, or are we watching really good system execution?
The answer to that question tells us everything we need to know about sustainability, about playoff performance, and about who we can actually count on when the lights get brightest and the games matter most.
Ready for the full breakdown of why this MVP hype might be missing the point entirely? Check out my video where I dive deep into the numbers and explain exactly what separates real elite quarterbacks from system products.
Leave a Reply