Put the parade floats away. Stop printing the “Run It Back Again” shirts. Cancel the Super Bowl LIX travel packages.
The Kansas City Chiefs are 5-5.
Read that again. Five wins. Five losses. Middle of the road. Not a dynasty, not a dumpster fire. Just average. Through ten games of the 2025 NFL season, the two-time defending champions are the mathematical definition of mediocrity. The scoreboard is the truth. That win-loss column doesn’t care about your feelings, your merch, or your quarterback’s place in the “all-time” conversation.
For half a decade, “Are the Chiefs vulnerable?” was the NFL’s parlor game. The answer was always a definitive no. Now the question is, “Are the Chiefs… boring?” And the answer, backed by every meaningful metric, is yes.
This isn’t a eulogy. The Chiefs are not dead. But they are, for the first time in the Patrick Mahomes era, mortal. This 5-5 record isn’t a slump. It isn’t a statistical anomaly. It’s not bad luck.
This is a reckoning. This is the bill coming due. This is exactly where they deserve to be.
The Numbers Don’t Lie: The Good Enough Offense
For years, the Chiefs’ offense was a force of nature. It broke scoreboards and shattered defensive philosophies. Now, it just sputters. It’s efficient between the 20s and seizes up when it matters. The numbers say it all.
Patrick Mahomes is still Patrick Mahomes. He’s 30, in his physical prime. He throws darts. He still makes two or three “how did he do that?” plays every Sunday. But his 2025 line so far, roughly 2,625 passing yards, 18 touchdown passes, and 6 interceptions, is a reminder this is not the unstoppable machine people worshipped without question. That stat line is fine. It’s good. It’s what you’d expect from a Pro Bowl quarterback. It’s not elite, not transcendent, and it’s certainly not carrying this flawed roster to blowouts.
Then there’s Travis Kelce. He’s still a future Hall of Famer, but the production is finally, definitively slipping. Through ten games, he’s at roughly 50 catches for 631 yards and 4 touchdowns. That is not vintage Kelce. That is not the safety-blanket-plus-YAC monster who was an automatic 100 yards in the playoffs. That’s a 36-year-old tight end, playing his 13th season, finally looking like one.
He’s no longer the guy who can single-handedly tilt a defense. He’s a very good possession receiver. The explosiveness has waned. The separation is measured in inches, not yards. Father Time remains undefeated, and he’s finally got Kelce in a 1-on-1 matchup he can’t win.
Team-level? The Chiefs are scoring and moving the ball enough to not be embarrassing, but they’re not dominating. They sit around the top 10-12 in points and yards per game, not at the top of the league. That looks like a good team on paper, and it’s exactly the kind of team that loses the close ones when it matters.
And that is exactly what is happening.
A Deeper Dive: Why 5-5 is Not a Fluke
Let’s look past the surface stats. The story of this 5-5 team is written in the margins. It’s the story of situational football.
The 2025 Chiefs cannot finish drives. They settle for field goals instead of touchdowns. They give the ball back instead of extending drives. They cannot create explosive plays, and they actively kill their own drives with mental mistakes.
This isn’t just about Mahomes and Kelce. This is the new angle everyone saw coming: the receiving corps is a liability. Outside of Kelce, the group is a collection of JAGs and developing-but-not-yet-developed draft picks. They are fast, but they can’t get open against savvy corners. They can’t win contested catches. They cannot, under any circumstances, be relied upon in clutch moments.
Mahomes’ “good, not great” stat line isn’t a reflection of him. It’s a reflection of a quarterback who has to play perfectly, check it down constantly, and has zero margin for error because his 36-year-old tight end is his only reliable option.
This Is Not Panic. This Is Consequence
There are three certainties in the modern NFL: death, taxes, and the salary cap.
Fans treated the Chiefs like a religion for half a decade. But this decline isn’t a mystery. It’s not bad coaching. It’s not a lack of “wanting it.”
This is the price of greatness.
This is the consequence of paying your generational quarterback a contract that takes up a gargantuan percentage of the cap. Patrick Mahomes is worth every penny. But those pennies mean you cannot also pay a $25M/year All-Pro wide receiver. You cannot also pay a $20M/year left tackle. You have to make choices.
The Chiefs’ choice, guided by GM Brett Veach, was to pay their core stars, Mahomes, Chris Jones, Joe Thuney, and build the rest of the roster, specifically wide receiver and offensive line, through the draft.
This is a brilliant strategy if you draft perfectly.
The Chiefs have not drafted perfectly. The 2023-2024 drafts produced solid contributors, but no game-changers at skill positions. They swung and missed on reclamation projects. They hoped their system could elevate average talent. And for the first time, the system failed.
They are 5-5 because you cannot pay a quarterback $50M+ a year and also have a supporting cast full of $2M/year receivers who lead the league in drops. The bill has come due.
The Wasted Defense and the Evolved League
Here’s the cruelest irony of the 2025 season: the Chiefs’ defense is magnificent.
For years, the narrative was “Mahomes has to win shootouts because the defense is a sieve.” Now the script is flipped. Defensive coordinator Steve Spagnuolo is conducting a masterpiece. Chris Jones, now 31, is still a monster. The young secondary, led by Trent McDuffie, is a top-5 unit.
This defense is holding opponents under 20 points per game. It’s 4th in the league in sacks and 7th in DVOA. It is a championship-caliber unit, and it’s being systematically wasted by an offense that can’t score 24 points.
This defense is holding up its end of the bargain, only to watch the offense go three-and-out or settle for another 38-yard field goal.
Simultaneously, the league has caught up. The two-high safety shell, a defense designed to take away the deep ball and force Mahomes to be patient, is no longer a blueprint. It is the default defense against Kansas City.
For years, Mahomes beat it by being patient and hitting Kelce underneath, or by waiting for Tyreek Hill to find a crack. Now Kelce is a step slower and the other receivers can’t beat the man coverage underneath. The league has adapted. They’ve called Andy Reid’s bluff. They are daring anyone other than Mahomes or Kelce to beat them.
And no one can.
The rest of the AFC isn’t scared anymore. The aura is gone. The Texans, Ravens, Bengals, and Bills all have the offensive firepower to match or exceed Kansas City. The Chiefs used to be the final boss. Now they’re just another tough game on the schedule.
Bandwagon Fans React Like It’s Personal, Because It Is
Here’s what real fans already know. Tons of the loudest Chiefs fans only became loud when the trophies did. They weren’t there when the team sucked. They weren’t there for the Todd Haley or Romeo Crennel years. They showed up for the merch, the highlights, and the Taylor Swift cameo on the sideline.
They built an identity around winning, not football, not the team, but the act of being dominant.
Now they watch their team look average, and they go through the five stages of grief. They blame the refs. They blame the offensive line. They blame the media for “willing” this into existence. They go emotional and attack anyone who said “this was beatable” a year ago.
That’s not fandom. That’s a flash mob.
I said earlier in the year, after a 20-17 loss to the Chargers, that this team looked fundamentally broken. I was roasted for it. Not because I hate Kansas City. Because I watched the tape. Because the data on their red zone failures and receiver separation was screaming fraud. I’m not glad about it. I’m not celebrating collapses. I just call what’s in front of me.
If saying your 5-5 team looks like a 5-5 team makes keyboard Chiefs fans cry, welcome to reality.
What This Should Teach Them and the Path Forward
You can’t be the golden boy forever. Patrick Mahomes is 30. Travis Kelce is 36. Great players age. Great teams rebuild.
The Patriots had their runs and then they had down years. That is the template. The Tom Brady/Bill Belichick Patriots had two distinct dynasties. In between, they were merely great. They were a playoff team that kept losing in the AFCCG or the Super Bowl. They were mortal.
That is where the Chiefs are now. They are in their mortal phase.
The window for this version of the Chiefs, built on the singular magic of the Mahomes-Kelce connection, is closed. It’s over.
The new challenge has begun. Can Mahomes, at 30, elevate a new, younger cast? Can Veach find him weapons in the draft that don’t cost $30M? Can Andy Reid, in his late 60s, evolve his offense again to win in a different way?
This is what separates the good from the truly immortal. This is what Brady did. He won his first three with a defensive-led team. He won his last four by becoming a pocket-passing distributor. Mahomes now faces his first great test: not winning the Super Bowl, but retooling for a second act.
If the Chiefs sneak back into the playoffs at 10-7 and win a game, fine. If they finish 8-9 and miss it, don’t tell me you’re surprised. The fans who thought the sun would never set on Kansas City’s little empire need a cold shower.
The Takeaway
The Chiefs are not bad. They are not great. They are, as of November 17, 2025, an average football team. The stats back it up. The salary cap explains it. The aging curve confirms it.
Patrick Mahomes still throws well. Travis Kelce still makes plays. The defense is still elite. But the drop in dominance is real, the offense is solid but not overwhelming, and the fans who treated winning like a permanent entitlement deserve this little taste of humility.
Maybe it makes the next ride, if it ever comes, that much sweeter. Maybe it just ends in a shrug. Either way, stop acting like you were owed forever.
Leave a Reply