Here is the brutal truth. The Bills have a generational quarterback and a front office that is turning that prime into a cautionary tale. If you ever screamed at your TV thinking “How the hell does Beane keep doing this?” you are not alone. You should feel free to start drafting a lawsuit in your head. The evidence is all there.
First: the basic facts. Buffalo is 4-2 and sitting in a messy AFC. Josh Allen is still doing Josh Allen things. Through six games he has thrown for 1,397 yards and 11 touchdowns with a 62.4 QBR. He is being asked to carry a roster with soft spots that matter in playoff football. You do not waste a quarterback by surrounding him with mediocrity and hope the playoffs turn into a movie. They will not.
You saw the Bills on Monday. You saw the problem in live color. Allen completed 15 of 26 for 180 yards with two interceptions. Buffalo was outgained 443 to 291 in total offense. James Cook was the only consistent threat on the ground with 17 carries for 87 yards. The result was a 24-14 loss where the roster looked physically and schematically outclassed. That is not a single-week fluke. It is a snapshot of what happens when roster construction is second rate against teams that finish drives.
Now let’s talk concrete personnel and real world numbers.
James Cook is the rare bright spot. He is averaging 5.0 yards per carry with 537 rushing yards and five rushing touchdowns this season. He is a legitimate weapon. One of the only Bills draftees in recent years who reliably moves the needle. Cook looks like a player you can build around. The rest of the roster? Not so much.
Wide receiver though is where the “sue him” joke stops being funny and starts looking like a filing cabinet full of receipts. Since the team moved on from Stefon Diggs the Bills have been cobbling together a receiving corps that reads like a wish list written by a caffeine-deprived intern. Dalton Kincaid leads the offense at tight end with 20 catches for 287 yards and three touchdowns which is useful but he is not a vertical separation-creating No.1 who dominates single coverage. Khalil Shakir has caught 25 passes for ~268 yards. He is a complementary piece. Keon Coleman the “big upside” pick from 2024 has 24 catches for 237 yards and two touchdowns through six games. That is not elite. It is not even close. Allen is throwing to tight ends and running backs to survive. That is not what a championship receiving corps does.
Free agency has not fixed it. The Bills signed Joshua Palmer to a multi-year deal that looked reasonable in March. In practice his production has been modest and he left the Falcons game injured. There are stories about the money and the fit. The early returns suggest this was not a game-changing splash but a middle of the market addition that has not consistently won 1-on-1 matchups. Analysts flagged Palmer as underwhelming which matters when you paid for playmaking.
On drafting: Beane has hits and misses. He deserves credit where it is due. Cook and Kincaid are real contributors. But since 2019 the list of transformational offensive skill players is thin. Too many mid-round picks are role players or projects. The GM’s job is to reliably turn picks into starters who can win playoff games. Buffalo’s draft hit rate in terms of true impact offensive difference makers is underwhelming. Independent draft grades and local draft coverage have repeatedly called the classes uneven. That is not something you ignore when you’re trying to win now with a quarterback like Allen.
Defense was supposed to be Beane’s safety net. Build the front seven. Stop the run. Win the trenches. Instead the unit has flashed and folded with maddening frequency. Late drives allowed. Third down extensions. Chunk plays surrendered. All stuff that lands squarely on personnel decisions and schematic fit. Coaching gets a pass but when players on the roster can’t get consistent stops in high leverage moments that is on the people who scouted and signed them. This is not narrative. It is game film.
And the optics do not help. Remember that radio appearance when Brandon Beane got testy when asked about not drafting a receiver earlier? That clip did not make him look decisive. It made him look defensive. It became the highlight reel because it is the clearest public moment where the GM had to answer for the exact problem we are watching on Sundays. Lack of elite receiving talent. Inability to fix it in a convincing way. A GM job is to make the hard calls. Not go viral for snapping at critics.
Now the ugly math. The AFC is beatable this year. Kansas City has vulnerabilities and sits at 3-3. The Ravens and Bengals are sputtering. This is Allen’s window. A real open path to January and beyond. If Buffalo does not take advantage it will not be because Allen fizzled. It will be because the roster around him was built on hope and stopgap pieces rather than difference makers. That is where accountability belongs.
So yes fans should be furious. Draft a ridiculous class-action lawsuit in your head if it helps you sleep. Put Beane on trial in the court of public opinion. Demand answers from the Pegulas. Call sponsors. Cancel season ticket conversations until you get a plan that looks built to win a Super Bowl not a payroll spreadsheet and whisper-it-hopes that chemistry fixes everything. “Roster malpractice” might be theater. Probably worthless in an actual courtroom. But the pressure that works is the economic and reputational kind. That is how GMs get moved. That is how rosters actually change.
Final note. Josh Allen’s numbers (1,397 yards 11 touchdowns through six games) and James Cook’s efficiency (5.0 YPC 537 yards) are raw data you should be angry about because they make the roster holes obvious and unforgivable. The Bills have a path this season. If they blow it because of conservative signings scattershot drafting and a defense that does not finish games the blame will not be in the stands. It will be in the GM’s office. Make some noise. Make it count.
Leave a Reply