Penn State just pulled the plug on James Franklin. The meltdown across X, Reddit, and message boards isn’t about football logic. It’s about comfort getting yanked away. Because for years, a huge slice of the fanbase was perfectly fine with being reliably decent. They cheered competence while quietly lowering their standards for greatness. Now someone raised the bar, and they screamed.

Let’s keep it real. Franklin did some things well. He rescued the program from bad years, brought in talent, and delivered winning seasons like clockwork. On paper, 104–45 looks great. But numbers stripped of context are useless. Most of those wins were the games you absolutely must win. When things got tighter, when the opponent actually mattered, Penn State under Franklin wilted. Rinse, repeat. That pattern is exactly why he’s gone. That’s why the administration ate the buyout and made a change.

If you still think firing him was some knee-jerk reaction, read the losses. Oregon in the Whiteout tore the ceiling off. Then came UCLA, a team with no wins, laying a beating on Penn State. Then Northwestern, the underdog, walks into Beaver and takes it at home. Three losses that stacked on each other. And suddenly, it’s obvious. Franklin isn’t the guy to take this program where it claims it wants to go. Fans shouting “disloyal” are mad because the ceiling was removed. That’s not football logic. It’s entitlement.

Here’s a truth social media refuses to face. Franklin’s Penn State ledger in big games is awful. Against AP Top 10 squads, he was 4–21. He was 1–10 against Ohio State. He was 3–7 against Michigan. These are the measuring sticks people in this region attach to greatness. You don’t get to sit on a throne whispering “we’re a contender” when your head-to-head record says you fold in pressure moments.

And yet, fans cling to memory theater. Two plays are trotted out as gospel in support of Franklin’s greatness. One is the Whiteout moment when Michigan had to call a timeout before the first snap because the Beaver Stadium noise made execution impossible. It was electric. It was viral. But that single moment is not proof of concept. It’s spectacle, not substance.

The second is the play everyone remembers as Block Six. Marcus Allen blocks the kick, Grant Haley returns it, and Ohio State goes down. Fans replay it like proof that Franklin delivered. Fine. It was beautiful. But it was a play. You don’t build dynasties on magic moments. You build them on repeated excellence. One blocked kick does not erase a decade of faltering when it mattered most.

That instinct to lean on iconic moments shows the fragility of fandom. Those highlights feel like turning points, but feelings don’t build programs. Trends do. Franklin’s ceiling was always obvious: climb to Big Ten contention, occasional bowl glory, maybe a flashy playoff run, but no consistency in beating the best. Under him, Penn State played like a respectable program with flashes of “maybe someday.” That was acceptable to many. It wasn’t acceptable to the people writing checks and setting bold goals.

Don’t pretend the buyout is the mountain in the room. Yes, it’s massive, around $48 to $50 million by most reports. Yes, it hurts. Yes, donors and faculty are howling. But Penn State chose to absorb it. Why? Because leadership judged that incremental gains weren’t enough. Someone finally held the program to real championship standards and decided Franklin wasn’t capable of getting Penn State there.

Coaching accountability isn’t what it used to be. NIL, transfer portals, and media pressure have sped up everything. If Penn State wanted the version of Franklin that cleaned up the place and won the easy ones, they could have kept him. But if a school wants regular national relevance, it needs a coach who wins big, develops elite quarterbacks, and outthinks the top-tier. Franklin didn’t prove that repeatedly. And if you’re furious, ask yourself when you started settling for “good enough.” That was the moment you started defending mediocrity.

Nobody’s demanding perfection. That’s stupid. But being satisfied with occasional flashes of greatness while regularly folding against real competition isn’t ambition. The fans screaming this was the worst decision ever are mostly defending comfort. They liked the bowl trips, the respectable finishes, the legendary homestand plays that flickered on social media. They’re mad because the school decided to aim higher. They’ll have to stomach bumps, turbulence, and maybe a rough coaching search. That’s the price of wanting more.

Bottom line: Franklin won the games you had to win and sometimes sprinkled in a masterpiece. He was dependable, not legendary. Penn State wants legendary now. The administration paid for the shake-up. If that stirs panic, fine. But don’t pretend it’s about reason. It’s about losing a safety net. Penn State fans loved being mostly good. That era just ended.

Click here to read more blogs

&

Click here to sign up for our FREE Newsletter