You knew this clip was coming. Shedeur Sanders went on ESPN Cleveland and said, “If you see the quarterback play in the league right now, I know I’m capable of doing better than that.” People are already sharpening their takes, ready to dunk on him for being confident, for being Deion’s kid, for being a rookie sitting third on the Browns depth chart. Fine. Let them clown. The hot take here is lazy. Confidence alone doesn’t make a quarterback. Neither does a famous last name. What matters is production, accuracy, decision making, and how those things stack up against the reality of what NFL starters are putting on the field. On that scoreboard, Shedeur’s college tape and numbers make his claim more than fair.

Let’s be blunt. Shedeur’s season at Colorado was the real deal. He threw for 4,134 yards and 37 touchdowns while completing better than 70 percent of his passes. He won the Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award and led the Big 12 in nearly every major passing category. He set Colorado single-season records and finished with an elite QBR. Those are not the stats of a guy who only talks big. That’s timing, accuracy, and processing at the highest college level. That level of consistency in completion percentage and touchdown rate is rare.

Now look at the NFL starters everyone will use to mock Shedeur. Tua Tagovailoa is slogging through turnovers with a QBR in the 30s to low 40s, killing drives despite having weapons everywhere. JJ McCarthy’s early 2025 numbers are a mess, with a QBR around 20 and a brutal touchdown-to-interception ratio. Trevor Lawrence and C.J. Stroud, supposedly elite, are not lighting it up either, both well below top-tier QBR territory and dealing with turnover issues. Russell Wilson, once a master of late-game magic, is sitting in the low 30s and struggling to move the ball in the Giants offense. Caleb Williams looks like the real deal and has solid numbers, but he’s not so far ahead that Shedeur’s college resume looks ridiculous next to his. Spencer Rattler is showing flashes and better numbers than some of the vets, but it’s still a small sample.

Want specifics? Tua’s QBR this season sits mid-30s with multiple interceptions and an offense scoring less than it should. Russell is in the low 30s with poor efficiency in key spots. JJ McCarthy’s QBR is about 20, flat-out bottom of the league. Lawrence and Stroud are each in the 40s, nowhere near the elite 70-plus you expect from a top starter. Caleb is the one outlier with a QBR north of 60, but even he’s still working through NFL reads. Those are the real numbers people should be looking at when they clown Shedeur, not the “he has Dad’s name” narrative.

Here’s the clean logic. Quarterbacks who turn the ball over, post low QBRs, or can’t sustain drives leave the door wide open. A quarterback who can deliver accurate throws, protect the football, and keep the offense moving is already an upgrade. That’s exactly what Shedeur did in college: elite accuracy, high touchdown rate, low interception rate, and proven production in a Power Five conference. That doesn’t guarantee NFL success. Nobody skips the learning curve. But it’s enough to say he could play better than a handful of current starters who are flailing.

Let’s call out the lazy takes before they multiply. Saying Shedeur “talks crazy” without looking at the numbers is weak. Saying he’s already a franchise QB off one comment is just as bad. The truth is in the middle. He has the college resume and the accuracy profile to match or beat plenty of NFL starters who are struggling right now. If the Browns ever give him a shot in a system that protects him and plays to his strengths, he could absolutely outperform the guys I just named. That’s not cockiness. That’s math and tape.

Here’s the takeaway for Browns fans and anyone paying attention: focus on substance, not noise. Shedeur pointed out a hard truth about the current state of NFL quarterback play and backed it with a college career that demands respect. The rest comes down to coaching, protection, and opportunity. The league has more bad quarterbacks than people want to admit. Shedeur just said the quiet part out loud. He should be judged when he gets snaps, but until then, stop pretending the mockery is clever. The claim isn’t that he’ll be better than all of those guys forever. The claim is that he could be better than several of them right now. Based on the numbers and the tape, that’s a reasonable take.

Call the clip arrogant if you need to. I call it a rookie being honest about his readiness, backed by production that stacks up against the guys starting on Sundays. When he finally hits the field, we’ll see if he’s right. Until then, anyone lining up to laugh at him better do the math first.

CLICK HERE TO READ MORE BLOGS