What would it take for a defensive player to win NFL MVP again? A season so ridiculous it feels illegal, plus a year where the quarterbacks don’t hand voters an easy choice.

And even then, I’m not confident it happens, because the MVP has basically turned into “Best QB Season / Best QB Story.” Defensive Player of the Year is where defenders get rewarded now. MVP is where defenders get politely ignored.

Why the NFL MVP Award Is Basically a Quarterback Trophy

Quarterbacks touch the ball every play, and the league is built to make that touch count. Rules protect them, offenses are spread out, and passing stats are loud. That means the MVP conversation is loud too: yards, touchdowns, comebacks, prime-time wins, highlight throws.

Defense doesn’t work like that. A great defender can wreck your entire game plan and still finish with a stat line casual fans shrug at. Even sacks, the one defensive stat everybody understands, can get brushed off as “scheme,” “matchups,” or “the rest of the line helped.”

The real issue is voters don’t treat defense like it’s eligible for MVP unless a defender basically hijacks the season’s storyline. That’s a brutal standard, but it’s the standard.

The Modern Problem: Even Historic Defense Doesn’t Move MVP Voters

Here’s the thing that makes fans mad and they’re right to be mad: a defender can have a season that dominates weekly game plans, wins DPOY, and becomes the scariest player in football, and the MVP conversation still won’t take him seriously.

Meanwhile, a quarterback can have a good-not-great season, land in a crowded field, and still get a random “someone liked him” vote. That’s not about value. That’s about the default setting in people’s heads. QB equals MVP candidate. Defender equals “great season, different award.”

So when you ask “what would it actually take,” you’re not asking for a normal MVP case. You’re asking what it takes to break a bias that’s been baked into the award for decades.

The Only Modern Blueprint That Even Got Close: J.J. Watt’s Chaos Season

If you want the last time a defensive player made MVP voters sweat, it was J.J. Watt in 2014. That season wasn’t just “best defender.” It was “why is this guy scoring touchdowns like a tight end and wrecking quarterbacks like a horror movie villain?”

Watt piled up sacks, tackles for loss, forced fumbles, and he didn’t stop there. He scored multiple times on defense and even lined up on offense. That matters because MVP voters don’t just want impact, they want impact they can point at on a scoreboard.

And even with all that, he still didn’t win. That’s the lesson. A defender needs more than “dominant.” He needs “dominant plus points plus moments plus the right league context.”

What Stats Would a Defensive Player Need to Win NFL MVP Today?

If we’re talking pure stats, the bar is higher than most fans want to admit. It’s not enough to lead the league in sacks. It’s not enough to win DPOY. It’s not enough to be the best player on a top defense.

A defender probably needs to do two things at once:

1. Put up numbers that look like they belong in a different era
2. Create game-changing plays that flip wins in a way everyone remembers

So let’s get specific, position by position.

EDGE Rusher MVP Numbers: The Most Realistic Path

If a defender wins MVP in today’s NFL, the safest bet is an edge rusher. It’s the position where production is easiest to understand and easiest to sell. Quarterback goes down. Ball comes out. Crowd loses its mind.

For an edge rusher to win MVP, I think the minimum “seriously, you have to vote for him” stat line looks like this:

• 24 to 27 sacks
• 6 to 8 forced fumbles
• 2+ defensive touchdowns (or multiple scoop-and-scores that directly win games)
• A pile of quarterback hits and pressures that back up the sacks
• Multiple signature games against contenders where he takes over

And he can’t just do it quietly. He needs prime-time strip-sacks, walk-off moments, and games where announcers spend the whole fourth quarter talking about how offenses are terrified to drop back.

Sacks are the headline, but forced fumbles and defensive scores are what turn “great defender” into “MVP-level value.” If you’re not creating extra possessions and points, voters will still talk themselves into giving it to a quarterback.

Defensive Tackle MVP Numbers: Interior Dominance Has to Be Loud

A defensive tackle has the hardest job in awards conversations, because interior dominance is real but it’s not always visible in box scores. You can ruin an offense from the inside and end the game with two tackles. Fans who watched know. Voters scanning stats often don’t.

So a DT MVP season needs production that screams through the noise:

• 15 to 18 sacks from the interior
• 25+ tackles for loss
• Multiple forced fumbles
• Pass breakups at the line and constant pocket collapse
• A defense that clearly runs through him

This has to be one of those years where every week you hear, “Teams are sliding protection inside,” and it still doesn’t matter. If the DT is just “dominant,” he’ll get All-Pro. If he’s “dominant and loud,” he has a chance.

Cornerback MVP Numbers: The Unicorn Season

Corners get punished for being great because quarterbacks stop throwing at them. That’s the whole job. Lock down your side and make the QB look elsewhere.

But MVP voters don’t like “avoidance stats.” They like splash plays. That means a corner needs the rare combo of being respected and still getting picked on just enough to pile up highlights.

A CB MVP season probably requires:

• 8 to 10 interceptions
• 2 to 4 pick-sixes
• A ton of passes defended
• Game-swinging plays in big spots, not just garbage-time picks
• A narrative season where he changes how opponents call the game

If a corner is simply erasing WR1s with no targets, that’s football genius, but it’s not MVP-friendly. To win MVP, he has to turn defense into points and make it feel like he’s scoring as much as the offense.

Linebacker or Safety MVP Numbers: You Need the Whole Buffet

Tackles don’t win MVP. They just don’t. A linebacker can rack up 160 tackles and most people will still say, “Cool, but what did he do that changed the game?”

So for a linebacker or safety to win MVP, it has to be the full-blown “do everything” season:

• 140 to 170 tackles
• 8 to 12 sacks or 6 to 8 interceptions
• 3 to 6 forced fumbles
• 2+ defensive touchdowns
• A clear role as the brain of an elite defense

This is basically asking one guy to be a pass rusher, coverage player, and turnover machine in the same year. That’s why it almost never happens.

The Hidden Requirement: Team Success and MVP Storytelling

Stats alone won’t do it. A defensive MVP season needs the right team situation, because “value” always gets tied to wins.

A defender’s cleanest MVP setup looks like this:

• His team wins 12 to 14 games and is in the top-seed conversation
• The defense is top two or three in points allowed
• The offense is good enough to win, but the quarterback isn’t running away with MVP
• The defender is clearly the identity of the team

If your quarterback throws 40 touchdowns, congratulations, you just handed him the narrative. Defensive MVP cases die the second the team’s QB looks like the reason they’re winning.

What Would Actually Have to Happen League-Wide

This is the part fans don’t want to hear, but it’s real. A defender needs help from the rest of the league.

He needs a year where:

• The top QBs are good, but nobody has the runaway “how do you not vote for him” season
• Multiple quarterbacks split the vote because their cases look similar
• The defender becomes the one story that feels different from the weekly QB debates

That’s how you open the door. Not by hoping voters suddenly become fair, but by forcing a situation where quarterback value arguments cancel each other out.

So What’s the Real Answer? A Defender Has to Win Two Fights

A defensive player trying to win MVP isn’t just competing with quarterbacks. He’s competing with the idea that quarterbacks are the only “valuable” players.

So the stats bar is extreme. The context bar is extreme. The highlight bar is extreme.

If you want one simple sentence that sums it up, it’s this: a defensive player needs an all-time season plus a messy quarterback year plus a top seed.

That’s what it takes now. Not because it’s right, but because that’s what MVP voting has become.

Final Take: The MVP Isn’t “Most Valuable,” It’s “Most Quarterback” Until Proven Otherwise

If a defender wants to win NFL MVP again, he has to put up numbers that make people feel stupid for leaving him off a ballot. He has to create points and turnovers, not just disruption. He has to be the reason a contender wins week after week. And he needs the quarterbacks to cannibalize each other’s cases.

That’s a lot to ask. It’s also why we haven’t seen it happen in forever.

And until voters start treating defense like it’s even allowed in the MVP room, “what would it take” is going to keep sounding like a dare instead of a real debate.

---

Get a 100% deposit match on Chalkboard

Use promo code HMM at sign up to claim a 100% deposit match.

Sign up with code HMM

New users only. Terms may apply.

Click here to read more blogs