Less than a year ago, Kyle Dubas was on a hot streak we haven’t seen since Jim Rutherford acquired Phil Kessel. Now there seems to be a contingent of fans and media who think he sucks at his job. Let’s be honest, Kyle took on one of the worst jobs in sports. He was tasked with giving an over-the-hill roster another chance. Unsurprisingly, he couldn’t do it.
He has never been given full autonomy to deconstruct the roster. Not from ownership, but rather because of his allegiance to older players who are giants in the game. I think if Dubas had his way, the Big 3 would be broken up, with likely only Crosby remaining. However, he couldn’t do that to Sid. There has always been this tightrope Dubas has had to walk. He has needed to get younger, but also make the team as competitive as possible out of respect for Crosby and Malkin.
Last year, he did a phenomenal job. He drafted Kindel, who immediately became a full-time NHLer. He traded for Chinakhov, who is a legit top-six winger. His bets in the following offseason didn’t work out. Neither Lapierre nor Nick Robertson has shown the ability to be a true young difference-maker. His bet on Carlile to replace Shea or Wotherspoon fell flat. There has been no replacement for Mantha’s departure.
What was he supposed to do, though? Run the same team from last year again? That team was fun to watch, but they were miles away from winning the Cup. So, unless you enjoy losing to the Flyers in the postseason, there was no reason to re-sign Shea or Mantha. They needed change. They needed spots for youth. They needed to make an earnest effort at staying somewhat competitive while really eyeing the future.
Dubas couldn’t acquire any legit young talent in the offseason because he didn’t have a high enough pick. He couldn’t complete a deal for Jason Robertson. His plan went awry, and maybe he can take some blame for that. Yet, let’s not forget the work he has done. He has built up a solid young crop of complementary pieces. He is just looking for the next Penguins superstar. There is only one way to get that guy, and it’s to suck.
Maybe Landon DuPont. Maybe it’s someone else. Either way, Dubas was given an impossible task, and his team may finally allow him to do what he actually wants to do: tear it down. It will suck, and it might suck for a couple of years, but the team needs to start acquiring top-end young talent. I think Dubas has always wanted this, and now is his time to execute. So sit back and enjoy the trade rumors and worry little about the product on the ice. Come back in two years and then analyze the job Kyle has done.