I don’t know how you announce a presidential pardon and accidentally invent the greatest baseball season ever played, but Donald Trump managed to do it!
Trump announced Thursday that he had given Pete Rose a posthumous pardon. In his announcement, he credited Rose with 4,256 hits “in a Season.”
Pete Rose had 4,256 hits in his entire CAREER!
Now that’s one hell of a season. At that point, you aren’t playing baseball anymore. You’re playing MLB The Show on rookie difficulty!
All jokes aside, there’s something about this whole situation that I can’t get over.
Pete Rose spent decades trying to get back into baseball’s good graces. He was banned in 1989 for betting on baseball, including games involving the Cincinnati Reds. Then in 1990, he pleaded guilty to filing false federal tax returns and served five months in prison.
Those are two separate issues, and that’s important because a presidential pardon doesn’t erase baseball’s gambling findings or automatically put somebody in the Hall of Fame.
MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred already removed Rose from the permanently ineligible list in May 2025, after determining that the designation wouldn’t continue beyond a person’s death.
Rose died in September 2024.
So think about how this played out. The guy spends all those years wanting another chance, passes away, and THEN baseball opens the door for his Hall of Fame candidacy. A year later, he’s getting a presidential pardon.
And we still don’t know whether he’ll actually get into Cooperstown!
The Hall of Fame’s Classic Baseball Era Committee next meets in December 2027. Rose is eligible to be considered for its ballot, but that doesn’t guarantee he’ll appear on it, much less get elected.
I can understand the argument from fans who say betting on baseball is an unforgivable offense. That rule exists for a reason. I can also understand why other fans look at the all-time hits leader and wonder how you tell the history of baseball without putting him in the Hall of Fame.
That’s a debate worth having, and it’s one that a presidential pardon doesn’t settle.
But there’s something pretty sad about the timing of all this. Pete Rose wanted to see baseball give him another chance while he was alive.
Now everybody gets to debate his second chance.. except Pete Rose.