I cannot believe I’m about to say this, but Rob Manfred is actually right about something. Baseball needs a salary cap AND a salary floor! The problem is that I have absolutely ZERO confidence the people running the sport are going to figure out how to implement it without screwing everybody over.
Manfred just told reporters that MLB owners won’t agree to a new collective bargaining agreement without a salary cap and floor. The players don’t want a cap, the owners won’t budge, and now we’re sitting here with the possibility of another lockout hanging over baseball. Wonderful! We have an incredibly popular sport generating billions of dollars, and the people involved might not be able to agree on how to keep it operating.
And for once, I actually agree with the idea the owners are pushing. Look at how baseball currently operates. You have teams like the Dodgers spending ridiculous amounts of money to build their roster while teams like the Pirates act like signing a free agent is going to put them out of business. How the hell is that supposed to be a sustainable system?
That’s why I want BOTH a salary cap and a floor. I don’t want a cap that just gives billionaires an excuse to spend less money. I want a system where the top teams have a limit and the teams at the bottom are REQUIRED to spend enough to compete.
MLB’s proposal reportedly includes a $258.2 million cap and a $180.2 million floor for 2028, with certain exceptions during the initial implementation. According to the league’s calculations, Pittsburgh would be one of twelve teams required to increase payroll to meet that floor. As somebody who watches the Pirates, that sounds pretty damn appealing!
Now, I understand why the players aren’t thrilled. Nobody wants to be told there is a limit to how much money they can earn, and they’re right to question whether the owners are actually trying to improve competition or just protect their profits. A salary cap that takes money away from players while owners pocket the difference isn’t a solution either.
But does anybody seriously believe the current system is perfect? That there isn’t something we could change to give more fanbases a realistic chance to compete? That’s what I want out of these negotiations. A system that actually makes baseball better, not another excuse for one side to keep more money.
And instead, we’re watching Manfred explain how he’s willing to work through Thanksgiving to get a deal done. Well, congratulations, Rob! I’ll send you a plate of leftovers. You know what I’d appreciate more? An actual agreement that keeps baseball on the field!
The current agreement expires December 1, and a lockout could begin December 2. That doesn’t automatically mean the 2027 season gets canceled, but it’s a pretty terrible way to head into another year of baseball.
Here’s where I think things might get even more ridiculous.
I have a feeling these owners will find some way to get the 2027 season played. Maybe they negotiate a short-term agreement, collect another year’s worth of ticket sales, TV revenue, merchandise and everything else baseball fans spend their money on, and then we’re back to the exact same fight in 2028.
I’m not saying that’s guaranteed. They could settle on a long-term agreement, or this fight could become a complete disaster before the 2027 season even begins. But I wouldn’t put it past the people running baseball to kick the problem down the road just long enough to collect another season of revenue.
And that’s what really bothers me. Baseball fans are the ones who will suffer if this goes badly. The people buying tickets, paying for streaming services, bringing their kids to the ballpark and supporting teams that haven’t given them much to celebrate in years.
I want baseball to change. I want a salary cap and floor that actually create a more competitive league. And I want the players to get a fair deal while making those changes.
What I don’t want is a sport that spends every few years threatening to shut itself down because nobody can agree on how to divide up billions of dollars.
So Rob, skip Thanksgiving if you have to. I couldn’t care less.
Just make sure the rest of us don’t have to skip Opening Day.